I found this article via TAMU’s library database in the EBSCO search engine. The authors are Yan Li and
Maria Ranieri. Li is an educator in the Department of Education at Zhejiang University and Ranieri is a
researcher in the Department of Education in the University of Florence. Their article was published
in 2010 by the British Journal of Educational Technology, is prefaced by an abstract highlighting the
main points of their article, as well as a technical framework detailing what their research referenced
as “digital literacy and digital competence.” The article is followed by an expanded list of references ,
the list of which does not include American authors Palfrey and Gasser, even though Li and Ranieri
conduct a similar study abroad.
Maria Ranieri. Li is an educator in the Department of Education at Zhejiang University and Ranieri is a
researcher in the Department of Education in the University of Florence. Their article was published
in 2010 by the British Journal of Educational Technology, is prefaced by an abstract highlighting the
main points of their article, as well as a technical framework detailing what their research referenced
as “digital literacy and digital competence.” The article is followed by an expanded list of references ,
the list of which does not include American authors Palfrey and Gasser, even though Li and Ranieri
conduct a similar study abroad.
This study, based on a randomly selected group of ninth grade Chinese teenagers within the Jiangdong
District in Ningbo City, one of the most industrialized cities not only in Zhejiang Province but also in all
of China, sought to measure the claim of whether the alleged “advantages” some students had over others regarding digital interaction, significantly correlate to how digitally competent the measured subjects were. Measuring the results of a controlled
test, the Instant Digital Competence Assessment instrument, against variables including grade size of the
targeted middle schools, length of time students had owned a Personal Computer or not, availability
of Internet and computer access, as well as frequency of use, showed that digital competence is not
defined by such variables. Rather, Li and Ranieri’s study suggests that technological ability varies among
individuals of differing cognitive capabilities that so-called ‘digital natives’ are not intrinsically adapted
to. Therefore, the authors conclude that growing up in a digital environment does not guarantee digital
competence because of differences among the individuals’ educational backgrounds and intellectual characteristics.
District in Ningbo City, one of the most industrialized cities not only in Zhejiang Province but also in all
of China, sought to measure the claim of whether the alleged “advantages” some students had over others regarding digital interaction, significantly correlate to how digitally competent the measured subjects were. Measuring the results of a controlled
test, the Instant Digital Competence Assessment instrument, against variables including grade size of the
targeted middle schools, length of time students had owned a Personal Computer or not, availability
of Internet and computer access, as well as frequency of use, showed that digital competence is not
defined by such variables. Rather, Li and Ranieri’s study suggests that technological ability varies among
individuals of differing cognitive capabilities that so-called ‘digital natives’ are not intrinsically adapted
to. Therefore, the authors conclude that growing up in a digital environment does not guarantee digital
competence because of differences among the individuals’ educational backgrounds and intellectual characteristics.
Li and Ranieri’s study was founded upon the grounds that “digital immigrants,” people born long before 1980, the advent of Internet and computer technologies, would not be as effective teachers unless their skillset matched the technological “superiority” of the “digital natives.” However, their study showed that further research into media education consisting of “information and communication technologies,” should be further applied in order to continually improve the Chinese K-12 school system.
Overall, this article implements logos, using graphs and statistics to show the validity of their research, and to discuss their sampling process. Ethical appeal only seems to be invoked throughout the authors’ scholarly backgrounds, but pathos appeal does not seem to be needed, or warranted. I found the rhetoric effective because the article gave me the information I needed to understand the study.