My Blog List

Friday, November 11, 2011

Scholarly Article Analysis on "Are 'digital natives' really digitally competent?--A study on Chinese teenagers"

I found this article via TAMU’s library database in the EBSCO search engine. The authors are Yan Li and
Maria Ranieri. Li is an educator in the Department of Education at Zhejiang University and Ranieri is a
researcher in the Department of Education in the University of Florence. Their article was published
in 2010 by the British Journal of Educational Technology, is prefaced by an abstract highlighting the
main points of their article, as well as a technical framework detailing what their research referenced
as “digital literacy and digital competence.” The article is followed by an expanded list of references ,
the list of which does not include American authors Palfrey and Gasser, even though Li and Ranieri
conduct a similar study abroad.
This study, based on a randomly selected group of ninth grade Chinese teenagers within the Jiangdong
District in Ningbo City, one of the most industrialized cities not only in Zhejiang Province but also in all
of China, sought to measure the claim of whether the alleged “advantages” some students had over others regarding digital interaction, significantly correlate to how digitally competent the measured subjects were. Measuring the results of a controlled
test, the Instant Digital Competence Assessment instrument, against variables including grade size of the
targeted middle schools, length of time students had owned a Personal Computer or not, availability
of Internet and computer access, as well as frequency of use, showed that digital competence is not
defined by such variables. Rather, Li and Ranieri’s study suggests that technological ability varies among
individuals of differing cognitive capabilities that so-called ‘digital natives’ are not intrinsically adapted
to. Therefore, the authors conclude that growing up in a digital environment does not guarantee digital
competence because of differences among the individuals’ educational backgrounds and intellectual characteristics.

Li and Ranieri’s study was founded upon the grounds that “digital immigrants,” people born long before 1980, the advent of Internet and computer technologies, would not be as effective teachers unless their skillset matched the technological “superiority” of the “digital natives.” However, their study showed that further research into media education consisting of “information and communication technologies,” should be further applied in order to continually improve the Chinese K-12 school system.
Overall, this article implements logos, using graphs and statistics to show the validity of their research, and to discuss their sampling process. Ethical appeal only seems to be invoked throughout the authors’ scholarly backgrounds, but pathos appeal does not seem to be needed, or warranted. I found the rhetoric effective because the article gave me the information I needed to understand the study.

Friday, November 4, 2011

Information Quality is definitely stifled by Information Overload

At this point in my life, I can definitely attest to the above assertion.

All this time, all I've ever wondered has been, Will I ever be good enough? Will my education, gifts or talents amount to anything of substantial worth to myself or anyone else? Truly, what difference can I make in this world? Or actually, how must I grow and learn to accommodate the necessity of making such a change?

Personally, it’s remarkable to think about how much calmness and confidence I’ve found posting in a blog forum, in asserting my voice, quietly yet publicly—an appreciative balance.

Now I ask different questions. Instead of Will I ever, I think How and where will I give first? To what sector of society will I choose to assert my voic, and credible opinions?

What is “Information Overload” to me?
Why, indeed, it is imagining that, with all the world’s sophisticated technology, software and forums of information existent, one cannot give to direct community and society at large. It is being distracted by the unimportant and extravagant information presented by illegitimate authors. It is doubting the power, purposefulness and persuasiveness of rhetoric. It is being so distracted by conglomeration of clutter, that the self-expression and enthusiasm one had once approached the subject matter with is forgotten.

Friday, October 28, 2011

Educational Reform

One might speculate upon the many reasons one would protest educational reform, as it is one of the most controversial issues to date. It is evident that teachers, as well as professors, are underpaid and overworked, for what seems to be a, somewhat, fiscally thankless job. Many consider the occupation of educator as a tedious and tiring chore, something only worthy of temporary involvement, but I am one of those people who think the role of educator is essential to learning and living well, even for individuals who do not venture to be involved, post college-graduation, much with the classroom setting, until they, like the majority of Americans, choose to have and raise children to complete their traditional ideals of an American family.
My argument is that our generation of Digital Natives is so infiltrated by the messages of various media that we, products of the 21st century, ought to acknowledge the need for disciplined instruction by physical presence of human beings in our lives. This is my definition of Information Overload: The Internet is cluttered with so much useless information of intellectual illegitimacy that it is altogether distracting from the objective information vital and imperative to the sustenance of one’s daily living.  In this age of information, every distraction is possible online and, according to the opinions of Digital Immigrants like Palfrey and Gasser, there is much risk to be acknowledged.

Friday, October 21, 2011

"Information Overwhelm: Two Types of Overload" Toulmin Analysis

An anonymous Harvard undergraduate student blogs about “Information Overwhelm: Two Types of Overload,” in order to expound to the general audience about how much the Internet affects our lives, as those whom Palfrey and Gasser call “digital natives.” The student’s claim consists of her qualifier that information overload is widespread enough so much that every user of the Internet experiences overload in at least one form. This claim suggests that every user of the Internet is subject to similar and consistent investments of time and energy in browsing the Net, once he or she attains Internet access.
Essentially this student describes two types of overload, as grounds to prove his or her mental conception of “information overload.” One is the “rabbit hole risk,” as the blogger describes how hyperlinks on Google, and, especially, Wikipedia, lead to an “endless and inescapable” cycle of inundated information. The blogger qualifies this evidence by stating that people are intrinsically inclined to procrastinate by indulging upon their boredom, which may spring out of a mental restlessness, an aspect which is essentially to promoting “rabbit hole risk.”
Another type of overload, denoted by this blogger, is “spigot risk.” RSS feeds (abbreviated for “Really Simple Syndication”) literally function as “inboxes for the Internet.” Google Reader is a classic example. One has the potential to subscribe to as many feeds as he or she desires and, thereby, constantly receives instant updates, linking to thousands of entire articles per newsfeed subscription. Facebook is another all-encompassing example of RSS “spigot risk,” as the student blogger characterizes it as “the single destination for social procrastination.” Ultimately the blogger qualifies these grounds of “risk” by stating that overload is “inevitable” due to the sheer volume of access to the limitless information the Internet provides. The blogger further qualifies this claim by attesting that the “inevitable” overload, or, in other words, the totality of all the information each user of the Internet encounters regularly, renders most of the information useless, if not incomprehensible. Thereby, the student blogger concludes that the question to ask is not whether overload is possible, but rather, how to relieve the “inevitable” stress of being overloaded, and to understand the risks involved in these “inevitable” experiences.

Source: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/digitalnatives/2008/11/03/information-overwhelm-two-types-of-overload/

Friday, October 14, 2011

Teach For America - Information Quality

Have you ever heard of Teach For America program? TFA is given a great rep among all Ivy Leagues and public universities as being one of, if not, the most prestigious non-profit educational organization. Their mission statement comprises of “eliminating educational inequality,” but test scores fail to reveal much of a deviation between their students’ test scores, and the tests scores of any non-TFA taught institution.
This subject is very important to me personally because of the laud that TFA has reached in the academic circles around me. I know at least three people who applied, and recently heard a friend say she was going to apply, even though she really didn’t visualize herself enjoying teaching much herself. She likes the idea of TFA and how much they would do for public schools throughout the nation, even though there is not much credible evidence aside from word of mouth, that TFA has improved the math skills, let alone reading ability, of the students taught by their teachers.
Teach for America turns down “underqualified” Ivy League graduates who allegedly do not meet the criteria of their classrooms. It is interesting to think that TFA’s own teachers have been accused as incompetent and not particularly skilled.
 I have subscribed to the TFA blog and have read multiple articles online about how TFA’s standards are most scrupulous and reserved for just the “best of the best.” Personally I’d like to see some academic progress match up with their “superior” expectations.
A friend of mine who achieved acceptance into the program told me how he basically had to cram-learn the content of an elementary-junior high level math course in order to pass their entrance exam, and ultimately, teach it. Just because he interned with the FBI doesn’t mean he’s a great teacher.
Essentially, Teach For America’s requirements are laid out quite high-handedly. Their requirements consist of:
·         “Demonstrated past leadership and achievement: achieving ambitious, measurable results in academic, professional, extracurricular, or volunteer settings
·         Perseverance and sustained focus in the face of challenges
·         Strong critical thinking skills: making accurate linkages between cause and effect and generating relevant solutions to problems
·         Superior organizational ability: planning well and managing responsibilities effectively
·         Respect for individuals’ diverse experiences and effectively working with people from a variety of backgrounds
·         Superior interpersonal skills to motivate and lead others
·         Thorough understanding of and desire to work relentlessly in pursuit of our vision”
-http://www.teachforamerica.org/why-teach-for-america/who-we-look-for/how-we-evaluate-applicants
I say we give TFA too much credit. Just because someone interned with the FBI does not mean that he is a capable teacher. Just because their organization hires people from every state, and specifically select a high proportion of Liberal Arts undergraduate majors does not mean all of them know how to teach, or have much experience doing so. My friend is with TFA and, in all honesty, it sounds like he’s struggling just like any other beginning educator would be.
I conclude that teachers start in the same boat, and natural aptitude cannot be measured, but developed through practice and experience. Care to qualify? By all means, please let me know.  The scope of "quality education" can be neither augmented or confined within one "club," and statistical studies do not suggest much improvement otherwise.

Friday, October 7, 2011

Rhetorical Analyses- Information Quality, Information Overload & Learning

Dana Boyd, in her blog post introducing her article, “Six Provocations for Big Data,” expounds upon how she does not find the information overload appealing because it is detrimental to our personal learning. Having presented herself with an overall ethos, displaying her educational information for all to see, Boyd points out to her audience that, as an experienced lecturer and educator, she is a legitimate source of information and will be able to give credible support for all of her claims. Indeed, she does not hold opinions contrary to the average educated college student, because, as she uses logos, she solidly introduces her work of research, and welcomes feedback from her followers and readers. Evidently, she writes for the general American public because she discusses a general concern, because it should be everyone’s concern whether or not the evident information overload they experience from technology, is ultimately gratifying, and whether their overall experiences would ultimately contribute to their overall knowledge, and hence, better their lives, which have become so interdependent on communication media across the World Wide Web.
In “The Internet is Frying Our Brains: Keep Calm and Carry On With Research Please,” Sarah Zhang, blogger on Harvard’s Digital Native forum, presents several news headline articles which showcase the claim that “information overload,” is indeed “frying our brains,” and depleting our information intake efficiency. In ethos appeal as a “Digital native,” and well-informed student, Zhang relates to and empathizes with her audience’s concerns over the quality of their online experience and learning. Zhang mildly states her own analysis, that concerns are largely unwarranted for want of adequate research, scientific, psychological, social and otherwise. In her opinion, because we do not have all the information about technological functions and digital decimation, we are not to jump to conclusions about how exposure to Internet forums and social networking is ultimately going to harm us physically, mentally, emotionally, relationally and otherwise. Zhang employs logos, using research to cite that neuroscientists’ alleged “proof” that a reliance on social networking contributed directly to attention-deficit disorder.
Sources:
http://www.zephoria.org/thoughts/archives/2011/09/14/six-provocations-for-big-data.html

Friday, September 30, 2011

Digital Reflections

Facebook has now become essential to post-modern communication. This new form of digital technology has forever revolutionized digital information exchange. Everyone nowadays has Facebook. One might speculate that the average college student has anywhere from less than 100 to up to 2,000 friends linked to their social networking experience.We are constantly besieged by a harangue of information about our friends’ personal lives and, even, daily epiphanies. Facebook has given us the capabilities of controlling our privacy settings in such a way that we can know exactly what any specific individual can preview, at any time.

Even though I moved to the industrialized city of Katy at 10 years old, as a fifth grader, because my parents have been traditionally conservative, I was only granted access to my personal cellular device, five years later, when high school started and I needed to coordinate carpool arrangements, for my after-school Orchestra sectionals, concerts and violin lessons, as well as for driving to various community service events throughout my involvement with my high school’s National Honor Society.  Although I am currently a sophomore in college, and have a year since, opened the “Pandora’s box” of various freedoms, sometimes I still feel, like, I am still behind culturally behind technology's rapid expansion. 





Friday, September 23, 2011

"Not Learning"

Diana Laufenberg: How to learn? From mistakes
TED speaker, Diana Laufenburg, 11th grade American History teacher at the Science Leadership Academy in Philadelphia discusses how she considers how the systematized, synchronized system of education as “not learning.” In this explorative intellectual analysis and scholarly speech, she chronicles her journey of teaching in different locations. Her visual presentation is simple: The images she has chosen to be depicted on the Smart Board behind her are to help document the locations of her teaching career but not to describe her whole journey.
Her primary means of appeal in this personal testimony is ethos because she, standing in front of the crowd, shows her audience that what she is a credible, caring individual and maternal figure who has genuine compassion and selfless care for the mental, physical, emotional and progressive wellbeing of her students.
To chronicle her journey, Laufenburg first displays a black and white 1931 photograph of her grandmother, followed by a still black-white picture of her parent’s one-room schoolhouse, in order to depict education in primitive conditions, given that her parental figures’ walking to school every day was the only standardized means of education present.
In her lecture she draws a comparison between “information scarcity” and “information surplus.” Laufenburg argues that failure is instructional and advocates the practiced actualizations of “experiential learning, student voice and embracing failure.”
She shows us pictures depicting her students’ experiences, one even of a student standing next to campaign posters, showing that he voted for the first time, after their class designed for their city an “election forum booklet,” in order to better inform and encourage the citizens of Flagstaff, Arizona, to participate politically.
In my opinion, ethos, or personal appeal is most effective because one has the ability to break down the barriers of interpersonal communication by  appealing to our common humanity and desires to flourish. 

Friday, September 16, 2011

Literal “Distance” Education

I took a distance education class this summer for a Political Science credit requirement needed to satisfy the degree requirements of my undergraduate major. It was interesting to learn that the general population of Americans, not excluding the demographic of college-educated citizens, would watch The Daily Show with John Stewart and The Colbert Report, TV programs of political satire, than keep up with current events via politically credible magazines and journals held more accountable to providing accurate information relevant to civic good and personal interest. That is, because the general public is largely uneducated, people may only tune into these stand-up comedians, and hence, fail to research much for themselves the people and platforms they vote into office.
Not everyone is an enthusiastic political science major, but as citizens of the United States of America, we are all entitled with the responsibility of watching over our government’s activities, the maintenance of “domestic tranquility,” as well as growth abroad in foreign markets of commerce and logistical cooperation. Therefore, we as college students, ought to take special interest in the daily and seasonal decisions of the legislative, executive and judicial branches of our government, and make conscientious efforts to sustain quality education, in whichever sectors of society we may find ourselves within an integral part of, in the future.

Friday, September 9, 2011

Information Overload, Information Quality & Learning

In the so-called “age of information” one may contemplate whether we are more educated than the people of the age before the printing press, and, ultimately, the advent of the Internet, in the 1990’s. When people had to punch out their own publications without high-speed Broadband Internet, they spent much less time surfing the net and considerably much more time with their heads buried in textbooks, “old school.”

Nowadays, people can have an average of five to seven browsers open at once. Is it much surprise many students claim not to have read their textbooks, when Cliff and Sparknotes are easily at hand? Is it much surprise when people become less educated in light of the fact that there are so many virtual worlds online one may engage himself or herself within?

What is the point of the classroom, when students can take distance education courses online, and read the textbooks for themselves? How much is the role of educators diminished, when “everything” is online, when people can just “Google it”? Are there many significant distinctions (of position and potential) in the corporate business world, when it comes to the quality of information one may attain? In fact, what are the differences between the educational institutions of a local community college to a state university versus an Ivy League education? If we all may have access to virtually the same amount of information, what separates the highly educated from the average community college graduate?

I hope to explore all these questions and more, as I proceed with blogging. Ladies and gentlemen, at your courtesy, please stay tuned.