My Blog List

Friday, October 21, 2011

"Information Overwhelm: Two Types of Overload" Toulmin Analysis

An anonymous Harvard undergraduate student blogs about “Information Overwhelm: Two Types of Overload,” in order to expound to the general audience about how much the Internet affects our lives, as those whom Palfrey and Gasser call “digital natives.” The student’s claim consists of her qualifier that information overload is widespread enough so much that every user of the Internet experiences overload in at least one form. This claim suggests that every user of the Internet is subject to similar and consistent investments of time and energy in browsing the Net, once he or she attains Internet access.
Essentially this student describes two types of overload, as grounds to prove his or her mental conception of “information overload.” One is the “rabbit hole risk,” as the blogger describes how hyperlinks on Google, and, especially, Wikipedia, lead to an “endless and inescapable” cycle of inundated information. The blogger qualifies this evidence by stating that people are intrinsically inclined to procrastinate by indulging upon their boredom, which may spring out of a mental restlessness, an aspect which is essentially to promoting “rabbit hole risk.”
Another type of overload, denoted by this blogger, is “spigot risk.” RSS feeds (abbreviated for “Really Simple Syndication”) literally function as “inboxes for the Internet.” Google Reader is a classic example. One has the potential to subscribe to as many feeds as he or she desires and, thereby, constantly receives instant updates, linking to thousands of entire articles per newsfeed subscription. Facebook is another all-encompassing example of RSS “spigot risk,” as the student blogger characterizes it as “the single destination for social procrastination.” Ultimately the blogger qualifies these grounds of “risk” by stating that overload is “inevitable” due to the sheer volume of access to the limitless information the Internet provides. The blogger further qualifies this claim by attesting that the “inevitable” overload, or, in other words, the totality of all the information each user of the Internet encounters regularly, renders most of the information useless, if not incomprehensible. Thereby, the student blogger concludes that the question to ask is not whether overload is possible, but rather, how to relieve the “inevitable” stress of being overloaded, and to understand the risks involved in these “inevitable” experiences.

Source: http://blogs.law.harvard.edu/digitalnatives/2008/11/03/information-overwhelm-two-types-of-overload/

2 comments:

  1. I really like the way the Harvard student describes information overload. The rabbit hole risk is so true in every way. I know I experience that almost every time I get online. It is amazing how addicting the Internet has become.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You did a great job analyzing the blog you chose, and I thought your use of quotations from the blog really added to your analysis. The blogger's different examples of information overload in the form of the "rabbit hole risk" and the "spigot risk" are very interesting and quite accurate. Great post!

    ReplyDelete