Have you ever heard of Teach For America program? TFA is given a great rep among all Ivy Leagues and public universities as being one of, if not, the most prestigious non-profit educational organization. Their mission statement comprises of “eliminating educational inequality,” but test scores fail to reveal much of a deviation between their students’ test scores, and the tests scores of any non-TFA taught institution.
This subject is very important to me personally because of the laud that TFA has reached in the academic circles around me. I know at least three people who applied, and recently heard a friend say she was going to apply, even though she really didn’t visualize herself enjoying teaching much herself. She likes the idea of TFA and how much they would do for public schools throughout the nation, even though there is not much credible evidence aside from word of mouth, that TFA has improved the math skills, let alone reading ability, of the students taught by their teachers.
Teach for America turns down “underqualified” Ivy League graduates who allegedly do not meet the criteria of their classrooms. It is interesting to think that TFA’s own teachers have been accused as incompetent and not particularly skilled.
I have subscribed to the TFA blog and have read multiple articles online about how TFA’s standards are most scrupulous and reserved for just the “best of the best.” Personally I’d like to see some academic progress match up with their “superior” expectations.
A friend of mine who achieved acceptance into the program told me how he basically had to cram-learn the content of an elementary-junior high level math course in order to pass their entrance exam, and ultimately, teach it. Just because he interned with the FBI doesn’t mean he’s a great teacher.
Essentially, Teach For America’s requirements are laid out quite high-handedly. Their requirements consist of:
· “Demonstrated past leadership and achievement: achieving ambitious, measurable results in academic, professional, extracurricular, or volunteer settings
· Perseverance and sustained focus in the face of challenges
· Strong critical thinking skills: making accurate linkages between cause and effect and generating relevant solutions to problems
· Superior organizational ability: planning well and managing responsibilities effectively
· Respect for individuals’ diverse experiences and effectively working with people from a variety of backgrounds
· Superior interpersonal skills to motivate and lead others
· Thorough understanding of and desire to work relentlessly in pursuit of our vision”
-http://www.teachforamerica.org/why-teach-for-america/who-we-look-for/how-we-evaluate-applicants
I say we give TFA too much credit. Just because someone interned with the FBI does not mean that he is a capable teacher. Just because their organization hires people from every state, and specifically select a high proportion of Liberal Arts undergraduate majors does not mean all of them know how to teach, or have much experience doing so. My friend is with TFA and, in all honesty, it sounds like he’s struggling just like any other beginning educator would be.
I conclude that teachers start in the same boat, and natural aptitude cannot be measured, but developed through practice and experience. Care to qualify? By all means, please let me know. The scope of "quality education" can be neither augmented or confined within one "club," and statistical studies do not suggest much improvement otherwise.
You explained The Teach for America program very well. I understand that the rogram looks for applicants with high standards, but I agree with you in that just becasue they meet the requirements does not mean they will be a good teahcer. This program seems very interesting.
ReplyDeleteI particularly enjoyed this post because I have been thinking a lot lately about becoming a teacher. One thing I wish you had done is explain a little more in the beginning exactly what TFA is. As someone who has never heard of it before, I struggled a little to grasp what exactly you were talking about. Other than that, it was a very original topic. I do agree with you that teachers should be more than just "qualified" according to TFA's standards in order to be a good teacher. Just because you are intelligent does not mean you can teach.
ReplyDelete